Preliminary study to identify criterion for quench crack. A change in the cooling rate reduces the probability of crack. The effect of time and temperature on austenitic grain growth a major qualifying project report. On the other hand, this phenomenon did not occur at quench temperature 220 c. When i was in school, i learned that if a piece of steel is cooled too rapidly during the quench portion of a hardening heat treatment, it might crack. The increase of toughness is also associated with uniform distribution of impurity. Highlights dqt heat treatment consists of two stages of quenching and tempering. A full bar means this is the highest value in the relevant set. The tendency for quench cracking is also increased with higher austenitizing temperatures.
This article discusses overheat ing and burning, residual stresses, quench cracking, and distortion in some detail and offers some suggestions to combat them. For some steels there is a specific cooling rate in the martensitic region at which the probability of quench cracks is maximum. These other types of embrittlement can exhibit similar intergranular fracture surfaces but are principally distinguished from hydrogen embrittlement by the fact that they are not time dependent. I even made a larger hand hammer out of 4140 since this has happened and did a full quench on it and it didnt crack.
The best way to prevent cracking would be to anneal the 4140 part before welding. The art of brazing is relatively simple, and the rules are common sense rules. If the use of water as quenching medium, 4140 steel cooling speed is faster at high temperature range, but the cooling speed is slow at low temperature range lower than the ms temperature. Overheating during the austenitizing portion of the heat treatment cycle can coarsen normally fine grained steels. Water quenched cring crack and the applied residual stresses during the cooling stage were investigated. As a result of this intermediate cooling rate, the parts will possess a hardness and strength somewhat greater than if annealed but somewhat less than if quenched and tempered. Distortion and crack prediction and experiments in. Intergranular fractures travel along the grain boundaries, rather than through the actual grains.
We routinely quench 4140 from 870860 deg c in water, and then temper back to 580 deg c and we will get pretty well spot on 302hb every time, having said that, we are quenching jobs in thickness over 60mm. So 4 develops good strength without the cracking and distortion that can result from water quenching. The study by scott 5 in 1925 will be introduced first. Jan 03, 2014 vegetable oil is actually a faster quench than normal mineral oil. According to the actual production situation, we believe that the main reason of quenching crack of 4140 steel plate is. Distortion in quenching an aisi 4140 cring predictions. Experimental steels 38crsi and aisi 4140 were subjected to austenitizing at 900 c for 30 min followed by annealing, quenching in oil and quenching followed by tempering at 400 c for 120 min. In the third phase of the quench, the part is returned to the intensive quench tank for further convection cooling very uniform cooling with no boiling to complete the hardening in the surface layer and in. The 800 600 400 200 30 oil 60 90 time, s 120 150 o fig. It is a fracture that follows the grains of the material.
The reason of quenching crack of 4140 steel plate article. Throughhardening low alloy steel bar 4340 colour code. It is identical to the carbon equivalent used to determine sensitivity to quench cracking. They are intended to give practical tips on what to try and what to look for. Here are 7 ways that steel can fail as a result of quench cracking from heat treatment. I am not sure if 4140 s correct austenitizing temperature. Metallurgical reasons for grinding cracks and their detection. Some metals will crack if quenched too repidly and 4140 is one of them. If the steel is an oilhardening steel, the use of these overly aggressive quenchants will lead to cracking. Keep alloy c 50 fpm, 1 gallon water per lb of castings remove highce parts at 300400f and air cool.
The dqt decreases impurities concentration at the prior austenite grain boundaries. The carbon equivalent ce is a good measure of determining if the steel is prone to grinding cracks. Occasionally, however, things do go wrong, and the brazing process fails to do its job satisfactorily. Quench cracks result from stresses produced during the transition from austenite to martensite, which involves an increase in volume. The 4140 bars came out fine, didnt need to retemper them. At quench temperature 230 c, 240 c, and 250 c, hardness of austenite was increased figure8. In the third phase of the quench, the part is returned to the intensive quench tank for further convection cooling very uniform cooling with no boiling to complete the hardening in the surface layer and in the part core. The hot parts are then quenched in a liquid, usually oil for medium carbon plate or alloy plate like 1045, 4140, or 4340 or water for low carbon alloy grades like a514. The aluminum oxide particles were probably added as a killing agent in the steeling practice. There are 31 material properties with values for both materials. While large 4140 rounds can be waterquenched, squares are a different story.
Quench cracks 3 ways to recognize speaking of precision. Troubleshooting brazing joints the harris products group. The occurrence of quenching cracks in highcarbon tool steel. Distortion in quenching an aisi 4140 cring predictions and experiments article in materials and design 42. Properties with values for just one material 5, in this case are not shown. Certain heattreatment processes such as hardening and quenching tend to increase the internal stress state of a material. However, additional searching of the literature may be necessary. It is possible to weld 4140 quenched and tempered but you have to be ok with at least some cracking.
The hot parts are then quenched in a liquid, usually oil for medium carbon plate or alloy plate like 1045, 4140, or 4340 or. The effect of single and double quenching and tempering heat. Quench cracks run from the surface towards the center of mass in a fairly straight line. Its well known that quenching most alloyed steels starting from aisi 4140 to high speed steels in water, brine, or sometimes oil will cause. Jade band marigold introduction atlas 4340 is a nominally 1. The aims of the research were to determine the cause of the cracks in high. Heavy section aisi 4140 forgings that need good depth of hardness can be a. The quench andtemper process induces enormous stresses, which can lead to part cracking during the process if good part design guidelines and proper heat treating practices are not followed. Welds that are to be quench and tempered after welding require the use of a 4 or 4140 filler metal, as most lowalloy filler metals of sufficient tensile strength lack the carbon required to respond appropriately following a quench and temper option.
Wisconsin hardening 4 steel 4 heat treatment chicago polymer quench. The improvement of toughness in the dqt is due to finer austenite grains. Making an improper selection of steel for the process. How to quenching and tempering of 4140 alloy steel. The dqt considerably improves ductility and toughness of aisi 4140 steel. Quench cracks do not have decarburization apparent, since the. Monotonic and cyclic stressstrain curves for 4140 quenched and tempered steel iteration 69.
Alloy description timkensteels 4140hw grade is a finegrained, lowalloy steel that offers optimum heattreat response in heavier crosssections. Quench cracks 3 ways to recognize speaking of precision blog. It is important for heat treaters to understand the mechanisms associated with quench cracking and to take all prudent steps necessary to avoid inservice product failures fig. Carburizing steels for case hardening usually have basecarbon contents of approximately 0. I still think that after working with it and studying it for 42 years. Intergranular fracture is the propagation of cracks along the grain boundaries of a metal or alloy. Jan 04, 2009 normalizing is heating to full hardening temp and then air cooling rather than quenching. The severity of the water quenching was responsible for the larger simulated distortion when compared with the oil quenching process.
She has a bs in metallurgy and materials science from carnegie mellon university and an ms in materials science and engineering from northwestern university. The quenching medium air, oil, water, molten salt, etc draws hear awat from the work at a some optimum rate. At 900 c, the specimen was considered as completely austenitized 100% austenite. It has the highest strength compared to the other variants of saeaisi 4140 steel. Atlas 4140 is a chromiummolybdenum throughhardening steel of medium hardenability.
Quench cracking in aisi 4140 low alloy steel fastener quench cracking along a line of aluminum oxide dross particles in a hex head capscrew. Quench cracking in aisi 4140 low alloy steel fastener. Avoid overheating and overly long dwell times while austenitizing. Quench cracking can appear to be associated with banding in the microstructure of the steel. Too much time between the quenching and the tempering of the heattreated parts. The check lists below will assist in such instances. Fabricating and repairing 4 and 4140 steels in heavy. Yes, even in these days of nanomiracles, steel is still useful and interesting. Ive checked all of my remaining reference books and none even give values for water quenching 4140. For heat treatment processes, high cooling rates commonly cause geometric.
To accomplish this task, we must work with design and manufacturing engineers on materials selection, manufacturing methods including heat treatment and safety allowances. Banding is a naturally occurring condition in any plate steel, and it arises as the ingot or strand cast slab cools from the outside in, which creates a slight variation in grain structure and chemistry through the crosssection. Distortion and crack prediction and experiments in quenching aisi. The graph bars on the material properties cards below compare quenched and tempered saeaisi 4140 to. I quenched and tempered the big 4340 beast, then had to wait a long time for it to cool down so i could use our portable brinell tester.
In normalizing, the cooling rate is slower than that of a quenchandtemper operation but faster than that used in annealing. If the use of water as quenching medium, 4140 steel cooling speed is faster at high temperature range, but the. Its chromium content provides good hardenss penetration, and the molybdenum. The martensitic transformation starts at the outermost surfaces of the part being quenched. Fourquenchingbathsofabout18 galloncapacityeachnamely,water,60percentglycerininwater. I should have used the oil quench tank to cool it off faster, but there was a reason i didnt. But they are also more susceptible to cracking, so its important to choose the right filler metal that matches the chemistry of the base metal for components to be annealed, normalized, or quench and tempered after welding. Hence, thegeneralruleofquenchingfromjustabovethecriticalrange. Apr 26, 2011 oil quench heat treating 4140 alex drechsel.
The heat capacity is another very important factor, and is one of the reasons to use oil instead of water. This was caused by the increase of carbon atom of austenite itself. Distortion and crack prediction and experiments in quenching. They have 72% of their average alloy composition in common. Because of their high hardenability, 4 and 4140 steels are commonly used for shafts, gears and forgings. Defects and distortion in heattreated parts asm international. Coarsely grained steels increase hardening depth and are more prone to quench cracking than fine grain steels. Gemerally i prefer a thin bodied oil for quenching but the actual type makes no real difference. Quenching from too high a temperature can cause cracking. The heat transfer coefficient between aisi 4140 and oil and water quenchants as a function of temperature has already been determined11, and was used in the present simulation. Yes, water, brine or caustic will get the steel harder. Here are seven ways that steel can fail as a result of quench cracking from heat treatment. Mar 28, 2012 it is important for heat treaters to understand the mechanisms associated with quench cracking and to take all prudent steps necessary to avoid inservice product failures fig.
Detail hobart brothers performance welding products. Asquenched martensite is hard and brittle it has virtually no ductility. During the heat treatment process in industry production, there are some problems, such as quenching cracks, related to watercooling and low. Selected major research works on quench cracking have been identified and outlined in chronological order. I am not sure if 4140s correct austenitizing temperature. The first step in the quenchandtemper is to heat the parts to a uniform temperature above the transformation range, usually about 1650. Distortion and crack prediction and experiments in quenching aisi 4140 crings da silva, a. Moreover, he makes a very important observation which is fully confirmed by this work, namely, that residual stresses. The occurrence of quenching cracks in highcarbon tool. The effect of single and double quenching and tempering. Six pieces of bar stock for each of the four grades of oil hardening steel 01 tool steel, 4140, 4150, and 4340 alloy steels were used for this test. In the quenching action, the steel is subject to nonuniform cooling, thermal deformation, and a phased grain transformation that can literally pull the. Avoid over heating and overly long dwell times while austenitizing. Besides it had to be developed for normalizing, as there are few if any quenching tanks big enough for an aircraft fusilage.
Based on my many rounds of specifying or actual heat treating of 4140 components you couldnt pay me enough to quench a part in water. Characterization of the performance of mineral oil based. The gray material in the crack interior is hightemperature oxide formed during tempering. While large 4140 rounds can be water quenched, squares are a different story. Other desirable properties include good wear resistance, excellent toughness and. A common misconception is that quench cracks can occur only while the piece is being quenched. Quench cracking along a line of aluminum oxide dross particles in a hex head capscrew. The quenched and tempered of 4140 alloy steel production process. Oct 24, 2017 debbie aliya is the owner and president of aliya analytical, inc. Novel waterair circulation quenching process for aisi 4140 steel.
1186 472 668 462 732 929 1662 1687 1670 597 1128 888 1191 1196 10 1424 1 1484 570 786 568 294 98 825 1254 653 80